<p>In the summer of 2024, your columnist spent several months in Bombay, staying at The Oberoi, Nariman Point, whilst undergoing medical treatment. His friend and colleague Ashish Jakhanwala, CEO of Samhi Hotels, dropped by to discuss a board matter. Over cappuccinos, Ashish remarked that nobody in the industry ran hotels quite like The Oberoi Group. Praise from a competitor carries more weight than a framed certificate in the lobby. He was right. But what, precisely, makes service exceptional? Granite bathrooms, monogrammed towels and a brigade of people saying “certainly, sir” cannot quite account for it. The answer matters well beyond hotels. Every manufacturer is, in an important commercial sense, in the service business. Its products are instruments through which customers meet their needs. Economists may require separate columns for manufacturing and services. Customers are under no obligation to respect the format.</p><p>Maruti Suzuki manufactures fine and reliable cars. Its customers buy mobility and convenience. Engine performance, safety and fuel efficiency matter enormously. But as Arnab Roy the company’s CFO explained to your columnist, so do an accessible dealer, available spares, an honest repair estimate and help when the car refuses to start far from home. Maruti’s extensive service network and round-the-clock roadside assistance therefore belong to the product’s value. While the factory supplies the vehicle, the ownership experience provides the verdict. Academics Stephen Vargo and Robert Lusch have developed this argument into what they call ‘service dominant logic’. Stripped of its scholarly jargon, the proposition is uncomplicated. Value emerges when something proves useful. A splendid industrial pump awaiting a replacement seal is currently providing an expensive demonstration of inertia. Consequently, manufacturers should measure success through customers’ working lives, including installation, maintenance and eventual replacement.</p><p>Research on service quality identifies five familiar ingredients, reliability, responsiveness, assurance, empathy and the physical evidence of competence. Put plainly, keep promises, respond promptly, understand the customer and maintain standards people can see. Reliability comes before theatrical trappings. Delivering breakfast punctually matters more than folding the napkin into a swan. Then comes ease. Research involving more than 75,000 customers’ experiences found that reducing customers’ effort mattered more to loyalty than elaborate attempts to delight them. Nobody enjoys repeating a complaint to four departments as good service carries information across the organisation and gives someone responsibility for the outcome.</p><p>The Oberoi’s underlying philosophy emphasises anticipating needs, attention to detail and respect for employees. Its investment in training gives those ambitions practical support. Such service requires observation and judgement. A guest recovering from treatment may value quiet more than conversation. Employees need clear standards, permission to exercise discretion and managers who support sensible decisions. A smile backed by six approval levels soon becomes a grimace. Mohit Nirula, the group’s Chief Operating Officer and a member of the IMA CEO Forum, offered your columnist another explanation. “You are kind and we are fortunate. The combined effect of the two is what you experience.” The familiar secret was people and culture. The less familiar one was that nice guests encouraged the best service. Courtesy sharpened employees’ sensitivity to unspoken needs; aggression put them on the defensive.</p><p>Research in hotels lends support to that observation, linking customer incivility with reduced proactive service, even where basic duties remained unaffected. This does not make competent care conditional on charm. An anxious patient or stranded motorist deserves help, however frayed their manners. But habitual bullies should recognise that intimidation can secure compliance while extinguishing initiative. There are limits to what shouting can purchase.</p><p>For business leaders, the test is practical. Measure whether problems stay solved, promises are kept and customers can get on with their lives. That requires leaders to examine the whole experience, including the awkward stretches that fall between departmental reporting lines. Reward employees for taking responsibility and investigate recurring failures rather than polishing apologies. Whether selling hotel rooms, cars or machinery, the commercial purpose is much the same. Make something in the customer’s life work better. The finest service leaves people feeling looked after.</p>
<p>In the summer of 2024, your columnist spent several months in Bombay, staying at The Oberoi, Nariman Point, whilst undergoing medical treatment. His friend and colleague Ashish Jakhanwala, CEO of Samhi Hotels, dropped by to discuss a board matter. Over cappuccinos, Ashish remarked that nobody in the industry ran hotels quite like The Oberoi Group. Praise from a competitor carries more weight than a framed certificate in the lobby. He was right. But what, precisely, makes service exceptional? Granite bathrooms, monogrammed towels and a brigade of people saying “certainly, sir” cannot quite account for it. The answer matters well beyond hotels. Every manufacturer is, in an important commercial sense, in the service business. Its products are instruments through which customers meet their needs. Economists may require separate columns for manufacturing and services. Customers are under no obligation to respect the format.</p><p>Maruti Suzuki manufactures fine and reliable cars. Its customers buy mobility and convenience. Engine performance, safety and fuel efficiency matter enormously. But as Arnab Roy the company’s CFO explained to your columnist, so do an accessible dealer, available spares, an honest repair estimate and help when the car refuses to start far from home. Maruti’s extensive service network and round-the-clock roadside assistance therefore belong to the product’s value. While the factory supplies the vehicle, the ownership experience provides the verdict. Academics Stephen Vargo and Robert Lusch have developed this argument into what they call ‘service dominant logic’. Stripped of its scholarly jargon, the proposition is uncomplicated. Value emerges when something proves useful. A splendid industrial pump awaiting a replacement seal is currently providing an expensive demonstration of inertia. Consequently, manufacturers should measure success through customers’ working lives, including installation, maintenance and eventual replacement.</p><p>Research on service quality identifies five familiar ingredients, reliability, responsiveness, assurance, empathy and the physical evidence of competence. Put plainly, keep promises, respond promptly, understand the customer and maintain standards people can see. Reliability comes before theatrical trappings. Delivering breakfast punctually matters more than folding the napkin into a swan. Then comes ease. Research involving more than 75,000 customers’ experiences found that reducing customers’ effort mattered more to loyalty than elaborate attempts to delight them. Nobody enjoys repeating a complaint to four departments as good service carries information across the organisation and gives someone responsibility for the outcome.</p><p>The Oberoi’s underlying philosophy emphasises anticipating needs, attention to detail and respect for employees. Its investment in training gives those ambitions practical support. Such service requires observation and judgement. A guest recovering from treatment may value quiet more than conversation. Employees need clear standards, permission to exercise discretion and managers who support sensible decisions. A smile backed by six approval levels soon becomes a grimace. Mohit Nirula, the group’s Chief Operating Officer and a member of the IMA CEO Forum, offered your columnist another explanation. “You are kind and we are fortunate. The combined effect of the two is what you experience.” The familiar secret was people and culture. The less familiar one was that nice guests encouraged the best service. Courtesy sharpened employees’ sensitivity to unspoken needs; aggression put them on the defensive.</p><p>Research in hotels lends support to that observation, linking customer incivility with reduced proactive service, even where basic duties remained unaffected. This does not make competent care conditional on charm. An anxious patient or stranded motorist deserves help, however frayed their manners. But habitual bullies should recognise that intimidation can secure compliance while extinguishing initiative. There are limits to what shouting can purchase.</p><p>For business leaders, the test is practical. Measure whether problems stay solved, promises are kept and customers can get on with their lives. That requires leaders to examine the whole experience, including the awkward stretches that fall between departmental reporting lines. Reward employees for taking responsibility and investigate recurring failures rather than polishing apologies. Whether selling hotel rooms, cars or machinery, the commercial purpose is much the same. Make something in the customer’s life work better. The finest service leaves people feeling looked after.</p>